Supreme Court of Virginia November 17, 1852 (Harper & Weston v. Baugh & Seguine)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-11-1852

Moncure, J.

I am of opinion that Harper and Weston are entitled to a grant for the 7429 acres, 2 roods and 12 perches of land claimed by them, and am therefore compelled to dissent from the opinion of the court in these cases.

A caveat is substantially and emphatically an equitable proceeding; and these being cross caveats, in which the caveators claim on the ground of “ a better right,” the decision of their conflicting claims must depend on the result of a comparison of their respec*510tive equities; unless, indeed, it shall appear that there is no equity on either side; in which case it would be. proper to dismiss both caveats according to the opinion of the court.

If the parties have any equity to compare, all will agree that that of Harper and Weston is superior. They seem to have acted Iona fide. They discovered that there was a tract of waste and unappropriated land in the Dismal Swamp, and desired to acquire title thereto in the mode prescribed by law. They did not, and until there was a survey could not, know the quantity of land contained in the tract. “ From the nature and situation of the land, lying as it does in an almost impervious swamp, often covered with water,” it was difficult, if not impossible, to make anything like a correct estimate of the quantity. They had two land warrants amounting together to 1110 acres, which they say they supposed would cover it; and accordingly, by virtue of those two warrants, they made an entry for the said tract on the books of the principal surveyor of Norfolk county, on the 7th of December 1844, minutely setting ont in the entry the abuttals of the land. And one of them stated to the surveyor at the time of making the entry, that if there was any land within the boundaries of the entry above the quantity expressed in their warrants, he intended to purchase additional warrants to cover the surplus.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.