Supreme Court of the United States February 19, 1852 (United States v. Armand Pillerin)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-02-1852
Mr. Chief Justice TANEY
delivered the opinion of the court.
These four cases are all French grants made after the treaty of Fontainbleau by which Louisiana was ceded to Spain. We have already decided in the cases of The United States
v.
Reynes, 9 How. 127, and The United States
v.
D’Auterive, 10 How. 607, that grants of this description are void, unless confirmed by the Spanish' authorities before the cession to the United States. In some of these cases evidence-has been offered
*10
.of continued possession by the grantees of those claiming under them, ever since the grants were made. But if there has been such a continued possession, and acts of ownership over the land as would lay the foundation for presuming a confirmation by Spain of these grants, or of either of them or any portion of either of them, such confirmation would amount to an absolute title, and not an inchoate or imperfect one. For all of the grants are absolute, or upon conditions subsequent; and if they had been originally madé by competent authority, would have passed the legal title at the-time, subject only to be divested by a breach of the condition, in the cases, where a condition subsequent is annexed. Such a title, if afterwards recognized by the Spanish authorities, is protected by the treaty, and is independent of any legislation by Congress, and requires no proceeding in a court of the United States to give it validity.
Titles of this description were not therefore embraced in the acts of 1824 arid 1844, under which these proceedings were had. These laws were passed to enable persons who had only an inchoate and equitable title, to obtain an absolute and legal' one, by proceeding in the District Court in the manner prescribed. And when the title under which the party claims, would be a complete and absolute one, if grafted by competent authority or established by proof, the District Courts have no jurisdiction under the acts of Congress above mentioned to decide upon its validity.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit