Supreme Court of the United States May 27, 1852 (Lawrence v. Caswell)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-05-1852

Mr. Chief Justice TANEY

delivered the opinion of the court.

This is an action brought by the defendants in error against the collector of the port of New York, to recover certain sums of money alleged to have been illegally exacted as duties.

The defendants in error are merchants of New York, and imported a large quantity of brandy in the year? 1847 and 1848, which were deposited in the public stores, under the Warehousing Act of 1846. Upon gauging these several importations, at the time of their arrival, the contents were found to be less than the quantity stated in the several invoices.

As the brandy was from time to time withdrawn by the importers, the collector demanded the duty of one hundred per cent,

ad valorem

upon the whole invoice quantity, and it was paid by the importers under protest.

The importers claimed in their protest that the duties should be computed upon the actual contents, as shown by the gauger’s returns, after deducting two per cent, from such contents. And the court was of opinion, and so directed the jury, that this was

*496

the correct mode of ascertaining the duties ; and a verdict was accordingly rendered and judgment given for the amount overcharged. This writ of error is brought to revise that judgment.

Two questions arise in the case: 1st, whether the duty ought to be computed on the quantity stated in the invoices, or on the contents as ascertained by the gauger’s returns: and 2dly, whether the two per cent, ought to have.been deducted for' leakage.

As relates to the first question, it is substantially the same with that decided by the court in the case of Marriott

v.

Brune, 9 How. 619. The duty of 100 per cent,

ad valorem

was chargeable on the quantity of brandv actually imported, and not on the contents stated in the invoices. This overcharge was therefore illegally exacted, and the defendants in error were entitled to recover back the amount. The judgment of the Circuit Court is in this respect correct.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.