Supreme Court of North Carolina December 5, 1853 (Poindexter v. . Gibson)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-12-1853
Battle, J.
The plaintiffs, if they ever were entitled to the legacies which they claim, are not barred
bjt he lapse
of time, because the fund out of which they are to be paid, could not be ascertained until the adjustment of the debt due John C. Blum, Clerk and Master, against the estate of the testator and others, in the year 1846 or 1847.
All the reasonable and proper expenses incurred by the executor, in defending the suit brought to recover that debt, ought to be allowed, if, upon enquiry, it should be found that any defence ought to have been made at alL The only question then, presented for our determination, is, whether, upon a proper construction of the will of the testator, the
feme
plaintiffs were, at his death, or when they respectively came of age, (if they were not so at the time of his death,) entitled to any share of the fund which he had specifically appropriated, first, to the support, maintenance and education of his children, and then to bo equally divided among them “ at their coming of lawful ago ?” At the time when the will was written and published, the children were all young, and stood in need of what was thus provided for them. But being of different ages, had their father then died, they would each have required a- different amount to be expended upon him or her, for the purposes mentioned, until he or she should reach the ago of maturity. In that respect, perfect equality could not well be attained, and the testator did not attempt it. In the events which happened,
*47
the testator lived nine years after the date of his will, and • his daughters had completed their education, and one of them had married a short time before, and the other married just after his death. The sons had also, during that period of nine years, been supported by their father, and partially educated at his expense; but, as their education was not then finished, they now contend that they were entitled to the whole fund, to the exclusion of their sisters.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit