Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court March 15, 1853 (Ball v. Burke)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-03-1853
Bigelow, J.
This case presents a question of some practical importance, arising under Rev. Sts. c. 85, § 13, which provides for the allowance of an appeal from the judgments of justices of the peace in civil actions. By St. 1783, c. 42j § 6, the right of appeal in such doses was expressly limited to actions in which both parties had appeared and pleaded. The section of the Rev. Sts. above cited, removed this restriction on the right of appeal, and gave it in terms to “ any party aggrieved by the judgment of a justice, of the peace in any civil action.” Under this provision, it has already been determined by this court, that an appeal will lie from a judgment rendered on a default. Holman v. Sigourney, 11 Met. 436; and it seems to us, that the words of the statute are quite broad enough to confer the same right in case of judgment on a nonsuit, and that such was the intention of the legislature.
By reference to the report of the commissioners for revising the statutes, it will be found, that this change in the statutes regulating appeals, was made upon their recommendation, and *81that they seemed to have had in view, in making the alteration,' the right of appeal by the plaintiff in case of a nonsuit, as well as by the defendant in case of a default. Rep. of Com. c. 82, § 6, n; c. 85, § 12, n. That such is the true construction of the statute, is made entirely clear by reference to section 10 of the same chapter, which provides for the very case of a judgment for costs against a plaintiff, when he fails to enter and prosecute his suit, as well as when he does not maintain the same upon a trial. The subsequent provision in section 13, which allows the right of appeal to any party aggrieved by the judgment of a justice of the peace in any civil action, must necessarily have been intended to include the judgment for costs against a plaintiff in case of a failure to prosecute his suit, which is specially provided for in a section of the statute immediately preceding it.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit