Illinois Supreme Court November 15, 1853 (Alton, Mount Carmel, & New Albany Railroad v. Northcott)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-11-1853
Treat, C. J.
This was an action of assumpsit, brought by Nortbcott against The Alton, Mt. Carmel, and New Albany Railroad Company. On the trial, the plaintiff read in evidence a written contract between the parties. It required the plaintiff to perform certain work on the road of the defendant; and it provided that the work should be estimated every sixty days by the superintendent of the road, and that the defendant should promptly pay four fifths of the value of the work estimated. The plaintiff then read in evidence an estimate of the superintendent, showing a balance due the plaintiff of $714.80, after deducting one fifth as retained percentage. The estimate was. of 1,300 cross ties. The contract required them to be one foot face, thickness eight inches heart wood.” The plaintiff then introduced the superintendent, who testified that he made the estimate. On cross-examination, he stated that of the 1,300 ties included in the estimate, only about 500 would face twelve inches on two sides, and eight inches on the other sides; that nearly all of the others were sixteen inches on one side, and eight inches thick in the middle, of heart wood, but they would not face twelve inches on two sides. The plaintiff then asked the witness if the ties, according to the usage of engineers, were suitable for the purpose for which they were intended, and a compliance with the terms of the contract. The defendant objected to the question, but the court overruled the objection, and the witness answered in the affirmative. The jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff for $714.80, and the court rendered judgment thereon.
The court erred in permitting the witness to answer the question objected to. It involved a construction of the contract. That was a matter for the consideration of the court, and not of the witness. It was the province of the witness to state facts, and that of the jury to determine whether the contract had been complied with.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit