Supreme Court of Georgia January 15, 1854, No. 74 (Raney v. McRae)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1854

By the Qowrt.

Lumpkin, J.,

delivering the opinion.

An action of assumpsit was brought in the Inferior Court of Stewart county, in 1840, by John N. McRae, against James H. Raney and William Y. Raney, on a joint note of the defendants, for $221 jifo- It was not alleged, in the writ, that either of the defendants resided in the county. James II. Raney alone was served. Immediately following the endorsement of service, on the declaration on James' H. Raney, by Robert Reeves, Sheriff, is the entry: “ Win. V. Ranoy not served, 14th April, 1840”; the Sheriff’s.namo not being subscribed.

*591James H. Raney, the defendant who was served, appeared and filed the plea of the general issue and payment; and at the trial term, confessed judgment for the debt, with cost of suit, tic entered an appeal, in his own name, to the Superior Court, giving one Bryant Ross, as his security. On the appeal trial, in July, 1842, he again confessed judgment for the wholo amount of the plaintiff’s demand.

At April Term, 1853, James H. Raney moved the Court to vacate tiro judgment rendered against him, because he and Wm. V. Raney wore sued together, as joint obligors, and he alone was served, and that his co-defondant was not served; nor did the Sheriff return as to him — that he was not to be found. And further, because said judgment was entered up for a sum, other, and different, and greater, than the confession was for.

fl.] As to the variance between the judgment and the confession, of GO cents, that is cured by the remitter voluntarily-entered by the plaintiff, and requires no further notice. The. maxim de minimis, if ever to be invoked, should bo applied on this occasion.

£2.] In England, in a suit upon a joint contract, if the facts do not appear from the plaintiff’s writ, that the other joint contractor is within the realm and in life, the defendant must bring it before the Court by a plea in abatement.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.