Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court November 15, 1854 (Bowditch Mutual Fire Insurance v. Buffum)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1854

Bigelow, J.

The plaintiffs seek to recover of the defendants the amount of certain assessments on a policy of insurance originally issued to Phelps, and alleged to have been transferred by assignment to the defendant. As an essential and primary element in the case, it was necessary to show an assignment of the policy by Phelps to the defendant. The original insurance was on the interest of Phelps in the property insured; the defendant was sought to be charged as standing in the right of Phelps, and was liable, if at all, for assessments due to the com. *552pany under and by virtue of the original contract of insurance, the obligations of which, as assignee, he is alleged to have assumed. He could not, upon the case stated in the declaration, be charged upon a contract of insurance originally made by the plaintiffs with him.

This being the relation of the parties, as appears by the pleadings and the evidence at the trial, the question is whether the rulings and instructions given to the jury were correct. If the case had gone no further than the ruling of the judge in the first instance, that, upon the evidence adduced by the plaintiffs, they could not maintain their action, there would have been some plausible ground for exception; but a special verdict having been taken at their request, and found against them, upon facts essential to the maintenance of their action, under instructions to which we can see no valid objection, they cannot now avail themselves of any error which may have existed in the original ruling of the court. The verdict of the jury has rendered that ruling wholly immaterial.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.