Supreme Court of North Carolina December 5, 1855 (Doe on Dem. of Freeman v. Hatley)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-12-1855
Pearson, J.
We do not concur with his Honor in his opin ion, either in respect to thetdeed, or the will.
As to the deed,
the objection is tire want of proof that it had been duly proven and ordered to be registered.
The proof is: the original deed is lost. In 1813, the courthouse of Montgomery was burnt, together with all the books and papers belonging to the clerk’s office, aftd also, those of the register’s office. A paper certified to by James M. Lilly, register of the county of Montgomery, which purports to be the copy of a deed that had been duly registered by him from J. K. Carson to William Thornton. This copy and certificate were made many years before the court-house was burnt, and James M. Lilly swears that at the date of the deed (viz., in 1811) he was the register of that county, and has been so ever since, and that no deed was ever registered unless the same had been properly proven, during the time that he has been register.
It is said for the defendant, “ that there is no evidence that the original deed had been duly proven and the probate ought to have been registered and constituted a part of the register’s certificate, so that the Court, and not the register, should judge that the same had been duly proven.”
In reply to the second position taken in this exception, it is
*118
enough to say, there is no Statute which requires the register to put on his books or which authorises him to' give a certificate in regard to the probate of deeds executed by a party resident in this State. When the party resides abroad, or when a commission issues to take the examination of the subscribing witness who resides out of the State, there is a provision in these words: “ whereon snch
decti/mus
and
certificate
of
probate
and
aclmoioledgment,
and the deed itself, shall be admitted to registration, &c.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit