The Superior Court of New York City February 15, 1855 (Sherman v. Partridge)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-02-1855
Dtjbb, J.
I. Taking into consideration the facts set forth in the plaintiff’s affidavits, and which I think might properly be given in evidence to sustain the averment in the complaint, of a special promise, I am clearly of opinion that the motion for the discharge of the defendant, and the substitution of Delafield as the sole defendant, must be denied.
An order of interpleader under § 122 of the Code, can only be properly made when the whole controversy turns upon the right of property, that is, upon the question whether the plaintiff in the suit or the claimant whose substitution as the defendant is desired, is the true owner of the debt, fund, or other property for which judgment is demanded. When the plaintiff insists as in the present case, that the defendant by a personal contract or otherwise, has rendered himself liable in all events for the debt sought to be recovered, and is precluded from setting up the title of a third person as a bar; it would be manifestly unjust to make the order, since in the language of Lord Cottenham in Crawshay y. Thornton, (2 Mylne & C. 1), it would deprive the plaintiff of his legal remedy, and *260might involve the sacrifice of his legal rights without affording him any equivalent or compensation.
Applying these remarks to the case before me, it is only in an action against the defendants themselves, that the question whether they have not rendered themselves absolutely liable to the plaintiffs for the price of the logwood can be so determined as to secure to the plaintiffs the right of appeal to the court of ultimate jurisdiction. To deprive them of this right by putting an end to this action in its present form, and substituting Delafield as the sole defendant; it seems to me would be an arbitrary and unwarrantable exercise of judicial power.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit