U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Southern New York June 13, 1855 (The Swan)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-06-1855

NELSON. Circuit Justice.

The H. H. Day was damaged and sunk on the Raritan river, in New Jersey, on the night of the Oth of November, 1850. some four miles below New Brunswick, having ran against a sunken canal-boat lying in the bed of the river, while on her way to Brooklyn. New York. The canal-boat was so far under water that persons navigating the river at night were unable to see where she lay.

The steam-tug Swan,' belonging to the claimants, left New Brunswick on the same evening with the H. H. Day, but some hours before her, for the city of New York, with six canal-boats and barges in tow, laden with coal and other articles; and, while proceeding down the river, met the propeller Erie coming up, which came in collision with one of the canal-boats with such violence that she immediately bilged and sank. The collision was owing to the negligence and carelessness of the propeller, without any fault on the part of the tug. The canal-boat thus sunk was the one upon which the H. H. Day. the vessel of the libellants, ran a few hours afterwards, occasioning the loss complained of in the libel. The captain and crew of the canal-boat were on board during the navigation of the tow, and at the time of the collision with the propeller, but were under the orders and direction of the master of the tug. According to the terms of the contract entered into by the master of the tug before the canal-boat was taken in tow. she was to be towed at the risk of her owners. After the collision, the captain and crew went on board of the propeller, and returned to New Brunswick.

The ground upon which the libellants seek to recover for the loss of the schooner and her cargo, occasioned by her running upon this sunken canal-boat, is the negligence and want of care on the part of the tug. in not placing a buoy or boat at the place with a light, or in some other way giving reasonable warning of the danger to vessels navigating the river.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.