Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court September 15, 1856 (Proprietors of the City Hotel in Worcester v. Dickinson)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1856

Merrick, J.

It was admitted by the defendant at the trial, that he executed the instrument, of which a copy is annexed to the declaration ; but he contends, for the various reasons which he has assigned, that no action upon it can be maintained against him.

1. He objects, in the first place, that it constitutes no contract between him and the plaintiffs, because they are not named in it as payees, or as the party in whose behalf it is to be performed. This objection, in view of the provisions of the instrument, as well as of the use which was made of it, both by those by whom it was signed, and by whom it was received, cannot be allowed to prevail. The instrument itself is without any date, and it is not shown precisely at whát time it was in fact executed. It Was however certainly after the enactment of the act under *590which the plaintiffs are constituted a corporation. Probably it was subsequent to their legal organization; for it appears that at the first meeting held under their charter a committee was appointed to procure subscriptions to the capital stock ; and the existence or circulation of any other instrument or paper, beside the one under consideration, has not been suggested. But the exact time when this was signed by the defendant is not very material. It is of more importance to consider the stipulations which are contained in it, the nature and extent of the obligations assumed by its subscribers, and the manner in which it was treated by the parties who respectively made and received, and who may therefore be presumed to have a direct interest in it.

It is to be observed, that the capital stock of the company is neither by the provisions of the charter, nor by the terms of the subscription, to consist of any fixed or stated amount. It was only not to exceed one hundred thousand dollars. This is a material consideration, and effectually distinguishes the present from the case of Atlantic Cotton Mills v. Abbott, 9 Cush. 423.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.