Supreme Court of Iowa December 15, 1856 (Robertson v. Seevers)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1856

Stockton, J.

The first question raised by the defendant is, as to the correctness of the instruction given by the court, at the request of plaintiff. That instruction was as follows:

“ That if defendant agreed to enter for hire or compensation, for plaintiff, the southwest quarter of northwest quarter of section 8, township 78 north, range 15 west, and through mistake entered instead thereof, the southwest quarter of northwest quarter section 8, town 76 north, range 16 west, the plaintiff can recover without making and executing, and tendering a deed for said last-mentioned tract to defendant.” The defendant insists that this instruction was erroneous, and that the court should have given-the instructions asked by defendant, which are as follows:

“1. That if the jury find that defendant agreed to enter a piece of land for plaintiff, and before the commencement of this suit, he entered by mistake, another piece of land, of equal amount and value, in the name of plaintiff, the plaintiff to recover, must show that before the commencement of this suit, he made out and tendered to defendant a deed to said land entered by defendant, by mistake; and that he *284made a demand of the money deposited, before he can re* cover.”

“ 2. That if he was acting as agent of plaintiff, and trying to enter a piece of land for him, and by mistake entered some other piece of land, he is not liable, if he used the prudence and care that were usually exercised in such cases.”

It seems, that during the progress of the suit, the plaintiff executed to defendant a deed of conveyance for the forty acres of land, purchased by mistake in plaintiff’s name; this deed was filed among the papers of the suit, for defendant’s use. It is contended, however, that plaintiff should have executed the conveyance and tendered the same to defendant, before the commencement of the suit. We do not think, that there was any such obligation resting on the plaintiff.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.