Supreme Court of Georgia November 15, 1857 (Pope v. Tucker)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1857

By the Court. —

Benning, J.

delivering the opinion.

Was the Court below right, in granting the motion for new trial ?

One of the grounds of that motion was, that the verdict was contrary to the evidence.

Was this ground well taken?

One of the pleas was the statute of limitations, viz: that the cause of action was one that had arisen, more than four years before the commencement of the action.

Did the evidence support this plea?

The evidence discloses a deed made by Instance Hall, the grandfather of Mrs. Pope, containing this clause: “I give unto my son Littleton G. Hall in trust, and for the sole use and benefit of his children, to have and to hold forever, a tract of land adjoining the two last mentioned tracts, and containing equal number of acres with one of them, and also a negro man named Perry, a negro woman Dorcas, and a girl named Rena.”

The title of the plaintiffs to Rena and her children depended on this clause: Mrs. Pope one of the plaintiffs, being one of the “children” of Littleton G. Hall, and having been married to Mr. Pope, after the date of the deed.

What interest, then, did she take in Rena and her children, under this clause ?

[1.] She took a vested legal interest. The trust was an executed, not an executory one. There was nothing to be *487done by the trustee. Jordan vs. Thornton,7 Ga. 517; Edmondson and Wife vs. Dyson, 2 Kelly 307; Glenorchy vs. Bosville, 1 Lead. Cas. in Eq.

A vested legal interest in Rena and her children, then, was what Mrs. Pope took under this clause. Such an interest is sufficient to support trover; and therefore, Mrs. Pope if she had remained unmarried might have brought trover, in her own name, for Rena and her children.

[2.] She married Mr. Pope. What interest did he acquire by the marriage? He acquired whatever interest she had; and he acquired that, interest absolutely.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.