Illinois Supreme Court April 15, 1857 (Harwood v. Tucker)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-04-1857
Caton, J.
We place our reversal of this decree, upon the ground that the remittance of $2,000 was made for the express and specified purpose of paying the draft drawn by Ellis & Sturgis upon the defendants, in favor of the complainants, so that it is unnecessary to inquire, what would have been the rights of the complainants upon any general funds in the hands of Tucker & Co., belonging’ to Ellis & Sturgis, at the time the former received notice of the draft. That such a draft against a general balance in the hands of Tucker & Co., and notice of it by them, created no legal liability in favor of Harwood & Marsh before they had accepted or agreed to pay it, is a point not controverted, but what are the rights of the parties in equity, on such a state of facts, I will not now undertake to say ; I consider it beset with difficulties, whether considered upon the authority of adjudged cases, or whether it be considered in reference to its influence upon commercial convenience. As we imderstand the facts of this case, it depends upon an entirely different principle, about which there can be really no dispute, unless it be, whether the remedy might not have been obtained in a court of law.
The facts of the case are simply these: Harwood & Marsh, in Cincinnati, purchased a draft of Ellis & Sturgis, on Tucker & Co., of Chicago, for $2,000 and paid them that amount, less exchange. At the same time Ellis & Sturgis remitted by express to Tucker & Co., that amount in bank notes, and advised them as follows:
Cincinnati, October 23, 1854.
H. A. Tucker & Co.,
Dear Sir : We hand $2,000 bank notes for Cr. Draw same amount, $2,000. Please honor Harwood & Marsh.
Respectfully,
Ellis & Sturgis.
We are satisfied, from the evidence, that at the time of this transaction, H. A. Tucker & Co.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit