California Supreme Court October 5, 1858 (Emeric v. Gilman)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-10-1858

Field, J., after stating the facts of the case, delivered the opinion of the Court

Terry, C. J., concurring.

The only question presented for consideration is, whether the private property of an inhabitant of a county is liable to seizure and sale on execution for the satisfaction of a judgment recovered against the county.

In support of the affirmative of this question, several authorities are cited by the appellant, principally from the reports of Massachusetts and Connecticut. Upon examination, they will be found to admit that the doctrine sustained by them is peculiar to the Mew England States.

In Massachusetts, the individual liability of the inhabitants of towns and parishes is treated as an exception to the general rule, and is founded upon immemorial usage. (5 Dane's Ab., 3 58; Chase

v.

Merrimack Bank, 19 Pick., 568; G-askill

v.

Dudley, 6 Met., 551.)

In Beardsley

v.

Smith, (16 Conn., 374,) a judgment was recovered against the city of Bridgeport, a municipal corporation—a circumstance which does not affect the principle in question— and the Court, in holding that the execution issued upon the judgment might be levied upon and satisfied out of the private "property of an individual member of the corporation, says: “We' know that the relation in which the members of municipal corporations in this State have been supposed to stand, in respect to the corporation itself, as well as to its creditors,

has elsewhere been considered in some respects peculiar.

We have treated them, for some purposes, as parties to corporate proceedings, and their individuality has not been considered as merged in their corporate connection. Though corporators, they have been holden to be parties to suits by or against the corporation, and individually liable for its debts.”

We are unable to find any adjudged case in the other States going to the extent of the Courts in Mew England, and, as we have seen, the rule is there regarded as peculiar, or founded on immemorial usage.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.