Supreme Court of North Carolina December 5, 1858 (Williams v. . Houston)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-12-1858

Pearson, C. J".

The equity of the plaintiffs is put on the ground, that they, being the next of kin of Mary Harriss, are entitled to the slaves.as purchasers, under the limitation, in; the deed of William Harriss, executed March, 1831. The deed, after conveying land and slaves to Houston in fee, declares the trust: “ To receive and pay the rents, hires and profits to Mary Harriss, for her sole use and support during her "natural life, and af.er her death, to pay over in remain■der to

her heirs,

for their exclusive use, the profits accruing, or that may accrue, from time to time, from the property aforesaid.”

We are of opinion, that the legal effect of the deed, was to vest the whole estate in the trust, in Mary Harriss, under the operation of the “ rule in Shelly’s ease,” and consequently, the plaintiffs have failed to make out tille in themselves^ as

purchasers,

and the bill must be dismissed.

“ The rule” was adopted for the prevention of fraud, and the substance of it is, where an estate for life, is given to one, and by the same conveyance, the property is given to his heirs,: in such a manner, that the same persons are to. take the same estate as they would have taken by operation of the law, had the whole estate been given to the tenant for life, he shall take the whole estate, and such persons shall take by operation, of law, and not. as purchasers, notwithslanding the ex-, press intention was, that the one should take a life-estate only,' and'- the others should take as purchasers ; the principle is. the

*280

same as that by which, if one seized in fee, in England, devises to his eldest son, in fee simple, the son shall take by descent, and not under the devise ; for, although the intention, that he shall take by the devise, is express, yet, such intention being in manifest fraud of the rights of third persons, shall not bo carried into effect.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.