New York Supreme Court September 13, 1858 (Palmer v. Haskins)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-09-1858

By the Court, Marvin, J.

This action was tried before me. I have long entertained serious doubts whether in an action for libel, slander or assault and battery, evidence of the wealth of the defendant was admissible, upon the question of damages. I had occasion several years ago, in Blacksmith v. Fellows, an action for an assault, to examine the question whether the evidence was admissible in such an action; and I came to the conclusion that it was not; and also that it was not admissible in actions to recover damages for libel or slander. Blacksmith v. Fellows presented other questions, upon which a new trial was granted, at a general term; my brethren expressing no opinion upon the question whether the admission of evidence of the wealth of Fellows was error. It was stated at the circuit, upon the trial of this cause, by the counsel, Mr. Martindale, that it was the practice, at the circuit, to admit evidence of the wealth of the defendant, in actions for libel and slander; and that such evidence had recently been admitted in the 7th district, after full argument. I permitted the evidence to be given. The question has now been fully and ably argued at the general term, and it has been carefully examined. In my opinion the pecuniary circumstances of the defendant, in an action for slander, or libel, are not involved in the issue, and evidence to show him rich or poor ought not to be received.

It cannot be necessary to state the general rules relating to damages in this class of cases—that the plaintiff is entitled to recover all the damages he has sustained, whether the defendant be rich or poor; that the amount of damages is in the sound discretion of the jury; and that they may give exemplary or vindictive damages, && The counsel for the plain*92tiff has furnished an able brief, arguing at length that evidence of the wealth of the defendant is admissible, as some guide" to a jury, in case they should conclude to give exemplary or vindictive damages.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.