Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court March 15, 1858 (Brigham v. Coburn)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-1858

Metcalf, J.

The demurrer in this case was rightly overruled by the superior court. The only cause assigned for it is the omission of the plaintiffs to describe themselves as assignees under the insolvent laws. They describe themselves as “ assignees of Stephen G. Bass, an insolvent debtor.” But no assignee of a debtor’s property can maintain an action, as *331assignee, unless he has been appointed under the insolvent laws, and has received an assignment of the debtor’s property, under those laws. Nor can any administrator maintain an action, as administrator, unless he has been appointed by the right judge of probate, and has given bond to perform his trust. Langdon v. Potter, 11 Mass. 314. Davis v. Davis, 2 Cush. 113. Yet he does not and need not aver, in a declaration, that he was appointed by the rightful authority, or has qualified himself by giving bond. 11 Mass. 314. By describing himself as administrator, he is understood to describe himself as a lawfully authorized and qualified administrator, without an averment that he is such. And if his authority is not admitted, he must prove it, or fail in his suit. So, as it seems to us, when an assignee of an insolvent debtor sues as such, it is to be understood, without his so averring, that he is assignee under the insolvent laws, (by which alone he is enabled to sue,) and has received, from the commissioner or judge of insolvency, an assignment of the debtor’s property; and that it is sufficient for the maintenance of the action, if he prove his qualifications, when they are not admitted. See 7 B. & C. 406.

In strict legal accuracy, the plaintiffs should have termed themselves assignees, not of Bass, but of his estate; as an administrator should term himself administrator, not of the deceased intestate, but of his estate. Whether, if this too common inaccuracy had been specially pointed out as a demurrable defect in the declaration, the demurrer ought to have been sustained, we have not inquired.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.