Indiana Supreme Court June 2, 1858 (Coats v. Gregory)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-06-1858

Hanna, J.

This action was commenced by filing with the clerk a claim against the deceased, sworn to under the statute, in the form of an open account for money paid, goods, wares, &c., sold.

At the proper time, the executor filed his answer of three paragraphs. They were, 1. A denial; 2. Payment; 3. That plaintiff and deceased were partners in the mercantile business, and in the lifetime of deceased, said plaintiff received of deceased all his share of the cash, notes, accounts and property of said firm, except those which were wholly insolvent.

To the second paragraph there was a general denial filed by way of reply; and to the third, there was a denial of the partnership, and of the reception of plaintiff’s “ share of the notes and accounts and property of the said firm,” in the same paragraph.

There was a trial by jury. Verdict for defendant. New *346trial granted. At a subsequent term a second jury trial was had, and second verdict for defendant. The evidence is in the record.

The plaintiff caused the executor to be subpoenaed as a witness, and to produce as evidence letters received by the deceased from the plaintiff, in regard to the business out of which this suit grew. The letters were produced, but when offered by the plaintiff as evidence, objection was made by the defendant, and the evidence was excluded. This ruling of the Court is complained of. The first letter offered was one dated September 16,1850, and purports to be an answer to one from deceased to plaintiff, dated on the 2d of the same month, and to give extracts therefrom, as well as from other letters received prior to that time, and also from statements furnished by deceased to plaintiff. No offer was made to produce and give in evidence the letters and statements from which the extracts purported to have been taken. The letter and extracts therein contained would have had a tendency to produce the impression upon the jury that the deceased was indebted to plaintiff.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.