Indiana Supreme Court June 2, 1858 (Johnston v. Niemeyer)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-06-1858

Hanna, J.

This was a suit commenced before a justice of the peace for a balance due on a note dated September 16th, 1854, due ten days after date. The defendant put in ■a general answer of payment. Judgment for the plaintiff. The defendant appealed to the Common Pleas. Jury trial, finding and judgment for the plaintiff.

Johnston, who was the defendant below, complains that the Court improperly rejected evidence offered by him upon the trial. This is the only question in the case. The evidence offered consisted, first, of two orders drawn by Johnston, after the note sued on was due, in favor of Niemeyer, on a third party, having first proven that said orders were paid at the dates thereof to said plaintiff, but witnesses stating that they knew nothing of the notes sued on; and, secondly, one Miller was offered as a witness to prove that, at the request of the plaintiff, and on his account, the witness got of the defendant, after the note sued on was due, eight thousand bricks, nothing being said by plaintiff or defendant about the same being a payment on the note *351sued on ; but that the plaintiff, at the same time, stated to 1 witness that the defendant was owing him, and he could not get any money out of him, and therefore he wished him to take the bricks.

Was the evidence admissible under the pleadings?

The act regulating the powers and duties of justices of the peace provides that “ all matters of defense, except the statute of limitations, set-off, and matter in abatement, may be given in evidence without plea;” and that “matters of set-off claimed by the defendant, shall be filed in writing before entering upon the trial,” &c. 2 R. S. p. 455, §§ 34, 36. A set-off is defined by the statute to “ consist of matter .arising out of a debt, duty, or contract, liquidated or not, held by the defendant at the time the suit was commenced, and matured at or before the time it is offered as a set-off.” Id. p. 39, § 57.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.