Supreme Court of Missouri March 15, 1858 (Harrison v. Cachelin)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-03-1858
Richardson, Judge,
delivered the opinion of the court.
When this case was first before this court (23 Mo. 117) it was decided that the defendants had no title in law or equity, and on the last trial they did not attempt to set up any, but relied solely on the statute of limitations.
*27The court gave the following instruction at the request of the defendants : “ If the jury believe from the evidence that the defendants and those under whom they claim have had open and visible possession of the premises in dispute under a claim of title adverse to the title of the city of Carondelet and of the plaintiff for the period of twenty years next before the commencement of this suit, they will find for the defendants.” If an instruction contains a correct proposition of law, it will not be exceptionable, if there is any evidence to warrant it, no matter how conflicting or how little it may be; but there must be some evidence ; and where the whole case turns, as this did, on a single point, an instruction like the one given, without any proof to support it, is not simply obnoxious as a harmless abstraction, but is pregnant with mischief as tend-to mislead the jury, in assuming facts that did not exist. I would be opposed to disturbing this judgment if there was the least evidence on which do base the instruction; but this is not a case of conflicting testimony, or of doubt, as to the side on which it preponderated, but a total absence of any proof to give color to the hypothesis on which the instruction was framed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit