Michigan Supreme Court May 21, 1859 (Evans v. Norris)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-05-1859

Christiancy J.:

The principal question in this case arises upon the construction given to the lease, in the charge of the court helow to the jury, which was, “That Norris was not bound by the terms of the lease to call for that portion of rent payable in board, as the same became due, and within the year, but was at liberty to call for the same in board at any time; and if Evans refused to pay the same in board when demanded, that then Evans was liable to pay the plaintiff the amount in money; and that if the defendant wished to avoid the payment of the rent in money or board at any future period, it was the defendant’s duty to notify Norris that he was ready to board any person sent by him, and demand that Norris should send boarders there within, the time prescribed by the lease.”

We think this charge was erroneous, and not warranted by a fair construction of the lease. The provision for taking half the year’s rent in board “as the same falls due,” applies, we think, exclusively to the first year’s rent; and such, on the argument, was admitted to be the express Words of the lease, though the word “first” is omitted in the record. As it applies only to the first year’s rent, it is quite evident, from the whole instrument, it should be read in connection with the covenant for the payment of the rent of that year, and as a part or qualification of that covenant, and clearly implies the assent and obligation of Evans to pay in that way, as much as that of Norris thus to receive it.

It is not optional with Evans to pay in money or board. He would not be at liberty to refuse the board; and though such refusal might render him liable to pay the money, it *372would be as damages (and not necessarily as the entire damages) for the breach of the contract. The cases cited by counsel for the defendant in error, as to the right of election to pay in one of two ways, do not therefor apply.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.