Supreme Court of Iowa October 31, 1859 (Mills, Horner & Co. v. Mabon)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-10-1859

WRIGHT, C. J.

The plaintiffs, upon the examination in chief, asked a witness, “whether the husk was improperly-constructed, with reference to running two run of burrs, and if so, wherein and how?” This question was objected to, and the decision overruling the objection is now assigned for error. The ground of the objection was not stated in the court below. It is now urged that the interrogatory is leading and suggestive. We are clearly of the opinion that the objection is not well taken. But if so, it should have been urged on the trial. It goes to the form and not to the substance of the inquiry. If presented at the time, the difficulty could have been removed, by changing the phraseology. Adams v. Foley, et al, 4 Iowa 44.

In giving a construction to the contract, the court held, that defendant was not only to construct the mill upon the plan referred to, but that he also warranted that it should do good work, and should manufacture an amount of flour per day equal to other good mills, having the same number and sized burrs and same motive power, whether upon the same plan or not.

The defendant claims that by the contract he only undertook that it should manufacture an amount of flour per day equal to other good mills, constructed upon the same plan. In this construction the court did not err. The warranty as to the capacity of the mill as compared to others, is general, and is not confined to those built after the plan or model named. The words, “other good mills,” are not consistent with the construction contended for by defendant. If his construction is the time one, then it would seem that the parties would have qualified or limited the language by adding the words, “ built after this plan,” or the like. Instead of this, however, the only condition named, is, that such “ other good mills,” shall have no moro or larger burrs and no greater motive power.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.