Supreme Court of Louisiana February 15, 1859 (Kessee v. Mayfield & Cage)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-02-1859

Buchanan, J.

The plaintiff sues for wages, as overseer of a sugar plantation belonging to defendants, upon a contract. He avers that he was engaged on the 10th April, 1856, at a salary of eight hundred dollars ;.his engagement to terminate at the end of the year ; that he was discharged, on the 22d June, 1856, without cause or provocation. He claims wages for the whole year.

The defendants plead that they had good cause for discharging plaintiff, namely :

1st. Incapacity.

2d. Cruelty to the slaves.

3d. Disregard of the instructions of defendants.

Defendants tendered to plaintiff and deposited in court the amount of plaintiff’s wages, under Ms contract, up to the time of his discharge; although they deny that lie was legally entitled to any wages whatever.

Upon the trial of this issue, the defendants offered no proof of the two first grounds, or causes of discharge, alleged in their answer.

In relation to the third of those grounds, it was proved that the instructions of defendants to plaintiff, as their overseer, were, that he was not to chastise the slaves himself; but, in case they merited chastisement, that the same was to be inflicted by the driver, with the assistance, if necessary, of other slaves, under the direction of the overseer ; that all personal collision between the overseer and the slaves under Ms charge was strictly prohibited.

It was likewise proved, that the plaintiff told witnesses that he would not obey those instructions, and that he actually flogged slaves with Ms own hand.

Disobedience of defendants’ instructions, thus deliberate and intentional, was inconsistent with the duty of the plaintiff towards his employers, and was a sufficient cause for Ms discharge.

The question of law remains, whether the plaintiff, thus discharged for a good and sufficient reason, was entitled to wages, and, if any, to what extent.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.