Supreme Court of Louisiana April 15, 1859 (Scott v. Bogart)

Buchanan, J.,

dissenting. The opinion of the majority of the court appears to me to overrule the case of Northern Bank of Kentucky v. Squires, 8th An., in which case I concurred, and have seen no sufficient reason to doubt the correctness of the doctrine therein contained.

I am of opinion that the Judgment of the District Court should be affirmed.