Supreme Court of North Carolina June 5, 1860 (Reeves v. . Long)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-06-1860

Manly, J.

We cannot perceive any sufficient reason for not carrying into execution the testator’s will in respect to the slave, Jesse.

It is certainly the policy of the law to keep the races of white and black distinct from each other, and to maintain in the governing race, all needful, legal authority^, and secure on the part of the governed unconditional subordination and obedience. This is a necessity of the condition of things amongst, us, and essential to preserve the civilization that happily exists. But we are unable to understand the force of the objection, that this policy is contravened by the clause of the will in question.

The substance of the arrangement, made for the slave, is, that, he shall be sold to a master, of his own selection, at the price of five hundred dollars. The power of selection and the lowness of the price, are the points insisted upon as vicious in their tendencies. But to hold that these vitiate tine purpose of the testator and make void his will, in respect to that slave, would be to exclude from the system of slavery every indulgence in its management, or at least, so to hedge it about, in this respect, as to make it stiff and harsh, and thus impart to it an aspect it does not now possess. Taken alone, the permission to choose a master, cannot be considered an unreasonable license. The price fixed is not so grossly inadequate for a man, between forty-five and fifty years of age, as to vsitiate this license. It is an obvious mode of giving effect to it, by widening the field of selection somewhat, and making it a substantial boon instead of a mockery. Thus disposed

*357

of, he is not the less a slave in law. The master holds him in the same absolute bondage in which all slaves are held, and is amenable for his management. If from any sense of obligation, he indulge him with liberties outside of the limits prescribed by law, the nuisance may be abated and the master punished.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.