Texas Supreme Court July 1, 1860 (Wyler v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-07-1860
Roberts, J.
The part of the charge of the court complained of is as follows: “In coming to a conclusion on these questions, it may be necessary to decide first by what means she came to her death, then consider whether she had a motive to commit suicide, and if so whether it has been shown, beyond a reasonable doubt, that she did not kill herself, or die from accidental causes. You will also consider whether it was possible or probable that she committedrsuicide, or died accidentally by the means of which you believe she died.”
It is contended that the tendency of this charge was to throw upon the defendant the burthen of proof, that the deceased did not commit suicide, and, that as defendant had not proved this, that he did the act himself.
We do not think the charge liable to any such objection. The object of the charge was to instruct the jury, in substance, that *188after considering the means by which she came to her death, her motive to commit suicide, if they believed she had any, and the possibility or probability of her having committed suicide by, or having accidentally died from, such means, they must be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that .she did not commit suicide or die accidentally.
Any possible obscurity or confusion of ideas that may have arisen upon this charge, was immediately removed by an instruction so clear and direct that its meaning could not be mistaken, which was that “if then, considering all the facts proved to your satisfaction, you are not satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused killed the deceased by some of the means specified, or by means of violence unknown, then you will find the defendant not guilty.”
This idea was presented in its proper connection throughout the whole charge, and the court might well decline to charge it again in another shape, as asked by the defendant’s counsel.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit