New York Supreme Court June 26, 1860 (People ex rel. Van Rensselaer v. Van Alstyne)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-06-1860
By the Court,
Hogeboom, J.
A certiorari from the supreme court lies to redress injuries committed by inferior tribunals or officers invested with judicial powers. (Lawton v. Commissioners of Cambridge, 2 Caines, 179. Le Roy v. Mayor &c. of New York, 20 John. 430. Wildy v. Washburn, 16 id. 49. Ex parte Mayor of Albany, 23 Wend. 277.)
Sometimes it is expressly authorized and its limits defined by statute, and then of course the nature and extent of the power, and the cases in which it is to be exercised, depend mainly, if not entirely, upon the provisions of the statute. (Matter of Wrigley, 8 Wend. 134. President and Trustees of Brooklyn v. Patchen, Id. 47. Roach v. Cosine, 9 id. 227. Rowan v. Lytle, 11 id. 616. Anderson v. Prindle, 23 id. 616. Niblo v. Post’s Adm’rs, 25 id. 280. Buck v. Binninger, 3 Barb. 391. Morewood v. Hollister, 2 Seld. 320.)
Sometimes there is no statutory regulation on the subject, and then the writ is denominated a common law certiorari. (Johnson v. Moss, 20 Wend. 145. Comstock v. Porter, 5 id. 98. Kellogg v. Church, 3 Denio, 228.)
In general, if not universally, the supervisory power of the supreme court over inferior tribunals, by means of this latter writ, only extends to questions touching the jurisdiction of the subordinate tribunal, and the regularity of its proceedings. If such tribunals neither exceed their powers nor depart from the forms prescribed to them by law, their decisions upon the merits are final and conclusive. (Birdsall v. Phillips, 17 Wend, 464. Prindle v. Anderson, 19 id. 391. People v. Judges of Dutchess, 23 id. 360.)
It will be seen from the above cases that even under such a limitation a considerable field remains for the exercise of the revisory power of the supreme court.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit