Indiana Supreme Court December 8, 1860 (Yater v. Judah)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-12-1860
Wobdeh, J.
On December 22, 1851, B. W. Stewart and J. G. Gross, executed a chattel mortgage on certain lumber, to Judah, the plaintiff below, to secure the payment of certain debts therein specified. Afterward the defendant, Ydter, wrote to Judah, as follows, viz:
“ Versailles, June 25 1855.
“ Jonathan Judah, Esq. Dear Sir:
“It is a matter of some importance to J. 0. Gross, that that oak lumber should be sold soon, or it will be worthless. I would say, in order to accommodate you and Gross, that I have agreed to take a note on one D. A. Brooles. I know him. He is good, but very slow. If you will consent to let the lumber go, I will see that you are paid as soon as I shall be able to get that much money from Brooles / and should he not pay me in some three or four months, I will pay you myself the amount of your claim, provided it does not exceed one hundred dollars.
“ Respectfully, James L. Eater.”
*229Judah let the lumber go, and this suit is brought by him upon the guaranty, claiming $81 and 34 cents.
Trial by the Court. Finding and judgment for the plaintiff for $72 and 98 cents, a new trial, on the application of the defendant, being refused. Ydter appeals. The evidence is in the record, and from it we can not perceive on what ground the finding and judgment can be sustained.
In 1856, Judah made out a statement of his claims against Stewart and Gross, making the amount of his claims $234 'and 93 cents, giving them credit for a lumber account for $133 and 30 cents, and claiming a balance due him of $101 and 63 cents. Entering into the sum of $234 and 93 cents, thus made out, was an individual account against Gross, of $77 and 29 cents, which was not provided for in the mortgage, and which accrued subsequently thereto. The appellant insists that the individul account against Gross, which was not provided for in the mortgage, and which accrued subsequently to its execution, could not go to make up any part of the claim for which he is liable on his guaranty.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit