New York Court of Common Pleas January 15, 1863 (Bogert v. Dean)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-01-1863
By the Court.
Daly, F. J.,
The only absolute interest which Bogert had in the premises, under the oral agreement between him and Delaplaine, was a right-to the possession until the first of May following; the paroi understanding between him and Delaplaine operating as a valid agreement for the occupation of the premises.from the time of the commencement of Bogert’s possession until the first of May thereafter, (3 Rev. Stat. 34, § 1, 5 ed.,) and this interest, Bogert could surrender or transfer by a paroi agreement, (3 Rev. Stat. 220, § 6,5 ed.,) but whatever may have been his interest, he surrendered and assigned it in writing, in that respect complying with all that the statute required (3 Rev. Stat. 220, § 6, 5 ed.)
The agreement to sell between Delaplaine and Dean was subject to the right of Bogert as lessee. In consonance with that agreement, which was in writing, Bogert, upon Dean’s promise to pay him three hundred and fifty dollars, if he" would surrender the premises on the first of October then ensuing, signed an agreement in uniting, by which he bound himself to do so, which writing, Delaplaine, with the assent of Bogert and Dean, agreed to hold for both parties. He held it until the purchase was completed, and on the day when it was completed gave it up to Dean at his request. This was a valid agree*261ment, founded upon a sufficient consideration, which Dean, after it was delivered to him, could enforce, and having been executed at his request and delivered to him, Bogert, in the want of performance on his part, was equally entitled to the benefit of it.
To entitle him to recover the three hundred and fifty dollars Bogert was bound to show that he was ready and willing to surrender up the premises on the first of October, unless a strict compliance with the condition on that day had been waived by the defendant, and if such were the fact, it rested with Bogert to show it. Benedict v. Lynch, 1 Johns. C. R. 374; Marshall v. 9 Ad. and Ellis, N.S. 791.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit