Wisconsin Supreme Court June 15, 1863 (Smith v. Omans)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-06-1863

By the Court,

PAINE, J.

The only question which it is necessary to determine in this case is, whether the homestead of the judgment debtor is liable to forced sale on execution where the judgment was rendered in an action of tort ? We are fully satisfied that it is not, but that the spirit and object, as well as the letter, of our constitutional and statutory provisions on this subject, exempt the homestead from sale on a judgment in .. any civil action. The principal argument to the contrary is based upon the use of the words “ debt,” “ debtor ” and “ contracted ” in the constitution and the statute. The latter provides that the homestead shall not be liable to forced sale “for any debt or liability contracted after the first day of January in the year one thousand eight hundred and forty-nine.” It is said that the word “ debt ” includes only that which is owed upon an agreement, and that if there were any doubt about that, the use of the word “ contracted ” removes it, and shows that the intention of the legislature was to include only debts founded upon contract. But this is giving to those words a much narrower sense than that in which they were obviously used. Eor the word “ liability,” used in conjunction with the word “ debt,” is broad enough to include all .claims, whether founded upon tort or contract. And although there may be a technical distinction between “ debt ” and “damages,” still the • word “ debt ” itself is commonly and generally used to describe all obligations to pay money, whether arising from contract or imposed by law as a compensation for injuries. And in this general sense the word was evidently used in this statute, and *397tbe word “ contracted ” does not mean founded upon a contract, but it was used in its more general sense as equivalent to “ incurred.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.