New York Court of Appeals September 15, 1864 (Bartlett v. Tarbox)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1864

Wright, J.

The defendant’s notes were transferred to the plaintiff in November, 1851, by. Elijah Brown, a former owner and holder. Two- defenses were interposed, First., that the plaintiff was not then owner, but that they were the property of Brown; and, second, a .set-off against Brown.. The.set-off claimed was the amount of a note'($283.83) made by one Huntington, which it was alleged the defendant sold to Brown in 1849, and which had been paid to the latter; also, for moneys received by Brown, to and for the use of the defendant, and money paid by the-latter to the former during the six years prior - to 1851; and also, for work. and. labor done and performed by the defendant for Brown, in the years 1846, 1847 and 1848. The finding of the referee disposes of both these defenses adversely, to--the defendant. -It is found that the plaintiff was, at. the. commencement of the action, the owner and holder , of the notes,‘having .purchased them-for a. valuable consideration; that at the. time of the sale of the Huntington note to Brown,, the defendant was indebted to him in a sum of money.exeeedingthe amount of the note, for certain professional services, toward the payment of which, by. an ageement between, .the parties, tlie note *500was to apply; and Brown, at the receipt thereof, in pursuance of the agreement, applied it in part payment of the defendant’s indebtedness; and that the defendant failed to prove any matter of set-off mentioned in his answer. The findings are not the subject of review in this court. It was competent for the Supreme Court to have reviewed the case, both upon the facts and the law, but our jurisdiction extends only to the determination of legal questions. We can not look into the evidence to determine whether the facts were or were not correctly found; but taking them as found by the referee, our. power is limited to the inquiry whether he deduced the proper legal conclusions from them.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.