Indiana Supreme Court November 15, 1864 (Smith v. Thomas)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-11-1864
Perkins, J.
Suit by George W. Smith against Thomas, Mullin, Snozoden, and Snowden, for mischievously loading a gun with a dangerous charge, and placing it in the custody of the plaintiff, to he discharged by him, with a view to his injury, etc.; which gun was discharged by the plaintiff in ignorance of the dangerous manner in which it was loaded; by which discharge the gun was burst, and the plaintiff badly injured, in this, that the thumb and forefinger upon his left hand were torn off, etc.
The defendants answered the general denial, and specially that the plaintiff" had full knowledge of the manner in which the gun was loaded before and at the time he shot it off.
The plaintiff" moved to strike out the second paragraph *70of the answer, claiming that it was included in the general denial. The court refused to strike out; which refusal, if erroneous, did no harm. The City of Aurora v. Cobb, 21 Ind. 504
Issues -of fact were formed and tried, and there were verdict and judgment for the defendants. Complaint is made of erroneous rulings of the court during the trial; but it will be unnecessary to mention them, because the evidence is upon the record, and places the case, beyond doubt, on its. merits; indeed, the plaintiff’s own evidence on the trial presented a state of facts that precluded a recovery by him for the injury he had received.
The case is this: The plaintiff, Smith, had a gun, which he lent to four boys, the defendants. The gun was loaded. The boys returned the gun loaded with a dangerous charge, for the mischievous purpose of having Smith kicked when he might shoot it off. The boys told Smith, on returning the gun, that it was loaded with the same charge as when he lent it to them, they not having discharged it. Smith, however, suspected the boys of falsehood, and afterward went to see them about it, but failed to find them.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit