Indiana Supreme Court November 15, 1864 (Slattery's Administrator v. Toledo & Wabash Railway Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1864

Worden, J.

Action by tbe appellant against tbe appellee to recover damages for causing tbe death of tbe deceased, Thomas Slattery, wbo was in tbe employment of the company as a brakeman on a train of cars, through tbe alleged negligence and carelessness of other servants of tbe company.

Demurrer to tbe complaint sustained, and judgment for tbe defendant. Tbe plaintiff below appeals.

*82The following extract from the brief of counsel for the appellant contains a sufficient statement of the case.

“ Slattery, the deceased, was brakeman on a freight train of the defendant, and was killed at Keller's station, in Wabash county, by the hind cars, where he was, loaded with wheat in bulk, being thrown down an embankment and overturned, whereby he was instantly smothered to death in the wheat. The injury was occasioned by the breaking of a switch-pin, which the company and its servants had carelessly left out of repair for days previous, knowing that it was insecure. There was no switch-tender. The whole care and management of the switch, and every thing pertaining to its security, was within the duties of the section-boss and hands under his control. The switch might be left locked up, and without receiving any attention for -■‘'ays and weeks together. The hands running the defendant’s trains had nothing whatever to do with the switch, and, in like manner, the section-boss and his hands had nothing to do with running the trains. The labors and duties of employees on the trains were altogether separate from that of the hands repairing the road, and one class of employees might be in employment if the other class did not exist. Their duties did not bring them into any cooperation whatever. This is sufficiently stated in the complaint. The complaint is besides distinct in saying that the company and its servants negligently and knowingly left the switch-pin out of repair for twelve days.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.