Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court October 15, 1866 (Alexander v. Carew)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-1866

Bigelow, C. J.

A question has been made at the bar of this court, which does not appear to have been raised at the trial of this case in the court below. It is insisted that it does not appear that the defendant had notice of the lease under which the plaintiff claims possession of the premises in controversy. This is true. But it is also true that it does not appear that he had not received such notice ; nor do the exceptions purport to state all the evidence which the plaintiff offered. This is not a case, therefore, where it is shown by the exceptions, or can be fairly inferred from them, that the defendant at the trial took the general objection, in the nature of a demurrer to the evidence, that all the facts proved in behalf of the plaintiff did not make out a prima farde case. On the contrary, we think it is apparent that the defendant relied only on a specific objection to the sufficiency of the evidence, and that the ruling of the court was limited to the single point thereby raised. The statement in the exceptions is, that the plaintiff did not prove that he or his immediate lessor “ had ever made any entry upon or been in possession of the premises.” This is the only omission to prove a fact which is set forth, and it is coupled with a prayer by the defendant for a ruling that “ on this evidence the action could not be maintained; ” which the court refused to grant. This, we think, indicates very clearly that the only point which was intended to be raised, and which was embraced in the ruling of the court, •.vas that which was based on the failure of the plaintiff to prove the specific fact stated in the bill of exceptions. It is the settled rule of practice that when a case is brought into this court by exceptions, which set forth the objections taken in the court below, no point is open in this court which is not fairly embraced within the objections taken at the trial.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.