Supreme Court of Iowa June 21, 1866 (Lyon v. Welsh)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-06-1866

Wright, J.

Welsh and wife made a mortgage, now held by plaintiff, to secure a note of $1,400. The husband made a statement in writing, under section 3399 of the ^Revision, authorizing the District Court of Johnson county to enter j udgment for the full amount, stating it, and for a foreclosure.

Plaintiff, in due form, filed a petition making Welsh and wife and certain incumbrancers parties, and praying a foreclosure.

Welsh answered that the agreement for confession was obtained by fraud, &c. The issue made thereon was referred, the referee found for plaintiff, and this was confirmed by the court. Defendants (Welsh and wife) then separately filed answers setting up usury. Plaintiff moved to strike both of their answers, which was sustained as to the answer of Welsh, and overruled as to that of his wife. And to test the correctness of these rulings both parties appeal.

*580i hdsbakd ^iSmyW homestead. I. On the plaintiff’s appeal, the question is, whether the wife, who joined in the mortgage, but did not sign the note, can permitted to> plead usury. The mortgage was in part upon the homestead of defendants, aQ(j determining if it was also upon other lands, she could be heard to make this defense. We unite in the opinion that her interest in the homestead clearly gives this right. She is interested, alike with the husband, in protecting this from any illegal or usurious incumbrance, and in reducing the amount of any recovery under which the same might be sold.

She is in no sense a stranger to the contract. It has been held that she has such an interest in the homestead as entitles her to redeem from a sale for taxes, when the husband fails for any cause to do so. Adams v. Beale, 19 Iowa, 61. And the right to defend it against the demand of the usurer would seem to be even more unquestionable. And, indeed, all of the decisions of this court, as to the rights of the wife in and to the homestead, are in entire accord with this right.

2. TJSVB.Y: °S?jaIg”n ment' II.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.