Supreme Court of Minnesota January 15, 1866 (Ross v. Worthington)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-01-1866
By the Cowrt
Berry, J.
Assuming in accordance with the decisions in Parrott v. Shaubhut, 5 Minn. 323, and Thompson v. Morgan, 6 Ib. 292, that the instrument on trial in this action, was, at law, invalid as a mortgage at the time of its execution, because attested by one witness only, (without now following those cases further,) it would unquestionably be in the power of a court of equity, in a proper case, to remedy a defect of that character, not only as against the maker of the instrument, but also against any person who acquired title from the maker with notice. 1 Lea. Cas. Eq. 192-3, 195, 198, *442558; 2 Lea. Cas. Eq. 34-5, 55; 1 Story Eq. Jur., Secs. 165, 166; Wadsworth v. Wendall, 5 Johns. Ch. R. 225; Schenck v. Ellingwood, 3 Edw. Ch. 175; Pub. Stat. p. 396, Secs. 58, 59.
1. In this case it appears that one Rogers, together with Edward Worthington, executed an instrument running to Lewis Worthington, the appellant, which instrument was in form a mortgage, save that it was defective because attested by one subscribing witness only. Subsequently Rogers executed a deed running to Ross, the respondent, of an undivided half of the premises attempted to be mortgaged. This deed was duly executed, and contained the following clause : “ Subject to a mortgage executed by F. W. H. Rogers and E. Worthington to Lewis Worthington, and also a mortgage to A. P. Foster, which said Ross is to pay or cause to be paid, so that the said F. W. H. Rogers shall not he held liable for the payment of any part or parts of the above mentioned mortgages.” In the first place, this clause is an express recognition by Ross of the existence of the defectively executed instrument, and of its nature as a mortgage, and this recognition is contained in a deed duly executed with all the formalities which should have been observed in the execution of the mortgage.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit