Supreme Court of the United States December 26, 1866 (Lanfear v. Hunley)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-12-1866
Mr. Justice SWAYHE
delivered the opinion of the court.
"We are met at the threshold of the investigation by the proposition, on the part of the defendant in error, that this court has no jurisdiction of the controversy between the parties, and that the case must be dismissed.
The defendant in error holds the lands in controversy by the right of preemption, under the laws of the United States; and it is admitted that his title is valid and must prevail, unless his adversary has proved a better one. The plaintiff in error insists that such a title is shown in the record, — by a grant from the government of Spain to Paul Toups, in 1796, confirmed by the acts of Congress” of the 8d of March, 1807, of the 12th of April, 1814, of the 11th of May, 1820, and especially by the act of the 18th of August, 1856.
Hone of these acts, except the one last mentioned, at
*208
tempted to fix definitely the locality and boundaries of the grant. Tlrat act refers to surveys made by Hawke, in 1854, and confirms them. The plaintiff in error claims according to these surveys. They include the land in controversy. But the confirmation by this act was accompanied by important conditions.
[The learned judge here read the provisos as given, supra, p. 206, in the statement of the case.]
These provisos expressly save the rights, whatever they may be, of the defendant in error.
The act, considered in its entirety, confirmed to the plaintiff whatever he was entitled to by virtue of the original grant, conceding that to have been valid. It neither enlarges nor diminishes what the grant gave him. It extinguishes all claim, on the part of the United States,, to the land covered by the surveys; but as regards all adverse claimants, it determines nothing, and concludes no one. .It gives to the settlers upon the land, in express terms, the right to institute and maintain the litigation necessary to enable them to test the validity of the surveys.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit