New York Court of Appeals June 5, 1867 (Davis v. . Morris)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-06-1867
Grover, J.
This action was brought by the Plaintiff, as receiver, to recover rent due upon a lease of lot 212 Broadway, in the city of Hew York, given by the Plaintiff’s predecessor, as receiver, to Hudson, one of the Defendants.
*229
The Plaintiff claimed to recover against the Defendant Morris upon equitable grounds, and therefore brought the case to trial at a Special Term, when the Defendants insisted that the cause should be tried by a jury.
This was- denied by the Court, and the cause tried without a jury. The Defendants’ counsel now insists that this was a waiver by the Plaintiff of any right of recovery upon strictly legal grounds, and that, unless it appeared upon the trial that the Plaintiff was entitled to recover in equity, the judgment dismissing the complaint should he affirmed, although it appeared that the Plaintiff was entitled to recover at law.
This position cannot be maintained. The Code (§ 69) abolishes the distinction between actions at law and suits in equity, and provides that thereafter there shall be in this State hut one form of action for the enforcement or protection of private rights. Section 142 provides that the complaint shall contain a plain and concise statement of the facts constituting a cause of action. Where, as in the present case, the complaint states facts showing, as the Plaintiff claims, a right of recovery both in equity and at law, the question as to how the case is to be tried arises. The Constitution, article 1, § 2, provides that the trial by jury, in all cases in which it has heretofore been used, shall remain inviolate forever; but a jury trial may he waived by the parties in all civil cases, in the manner to he prescribed by law. At the time of the adoption of the Constitution all cases at common law were tried by jury.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit