New York Court of Appeals March 5, 1867 (Irving Bank of New York v. Wetherald)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-03-1867
Hunt, J.
Both the judge at the Circuit, and the General Term, are of the opinion that the notice by the Plaintiffs to the Seventh Ward Bank, of the mistake in certifying Wilson’s check to be good, before any steps had been taken, or any measures omitted by the Seventh Ward Bank, and while there was still time to fix all the parties upon the note, relieved the Plaintiffs from their liability on the certificate. In this opinion I concur. Such a certificate possessed no extraordinary or hidden power. It should impose no greater liability than its terms fairly require.
Divested of all technical terms, the transaction in question was simply this: The Seventh Ward Bank present for payment, at the Irving Bank, where it was made payable, the note of Morris Wilson. The making the note payable there, was a warrant from the maker to the latter bank, to pay it from his funds, and charge it to him. When the note is presented, the teller of the paying bank infoxuns the presenter that the note is good; in other woi'ds, that the maker has the funds in the bank to meet it. This information may be communicated verbally, by letter, or by a memorandum on the note, ordinai-ily called a certificate. If the note were presented by an individual, the money would ordinarily be paid to him, in satisfaction, and the note left with the paying
*122
bank. In tbe case of a bank, tbe note is taken back by tbe party owning it, to be returned tbe next day in tbe settlement of exchanges, as an item of credit in its favor and against the certifying bank. This is tbe usual course of business in tbe city of New York. The correctness of this certificate is a matter which tbe certifying bank has tbe means of knowing, and it is bound to state correctly. If tbe presenting bank relies upon its accuracy, and fails to charge tbe endorsers, as upon non-payment on presentation, tbe certifying bank- is estopped from denying tbe truth of its statement.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit