Supreme Court of North Carolina June 5, 1867 (McArthur v. . Johnson)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-06-1867

Battle, J.

The decision of this case depends upon the question whether the fraud alleged to have been practiced •upon John L. McArthur, in the execution of the power of attorney to Daniel McLean, under whom the plaintiff claims, was a fraud in the

factum

of the deed, or a fraud in the consideration of it, or in some matter collateral to it. It is a well established distinction that, for a fraud of the first kind, the deed may be avoided at law, while for a fraud of

*319

either of the two last kinds relief can be had only in a. Court of Equity; Reed v.

Moore,

3 Ire., 310;

Canoy

v.

Troutman,

7 Ire., 155;

Gant

v.

Hunsucker,

12 Ire., 254;

Nichols

v.

Holmes,

1 Jon., 360;

Gwynn

v.

Hodge,

4 Jon., 168;

Logan

v.

Simmons,

1 Dev. & Bat., 13.

An instance of fraud in the

factum

is when the grantor intends to execute a certain deed, and another is surreptitiously substituted in the place of it. See

Gant

v.

Hunsucker

and

Nichols

v.

Holmes, ubi supra.

Another instance is afforded by the case of a deed executed by a blind or illiterate person, when it has been read falsely to him upon his request to have it read; 2 Black Com., 304;

Manser’s

case, 2 Coke’s Rep., 3. These authorities show that the* party was fraudulently made to sign, seal and deliver a different instrument from that which he intended,' so that it could not be said to be

his deed.

Several of the cases in our Reports referred to above furnish examples of what is meant by fraud in the consideration of the deed, or in the false representation of some matter or thing collateral to it. In all of them it will be seen that the party knowingly executes the very instrument which he intended, but is induced to do so by means ot some fraud in the treaty, or some fraudulent representation or pretence. In this category is included the case of a man who can read the instrument which he signs, seals and delivers, but refuses or neglects to do so.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.