West Virginia Supreme Court July 15, 1867 (Kuykendall v. Ruckman)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-07-1867
Brown, President.
This was an action of debt on a bond payable on demand, against three obligors, who pleaded non est factum. The plaintiffs in the court below, after proving the signature of *337one of the obligors to the said bond, but without having proved the signatures of the other two obligors, offered the bond in evidence to the jury, to which the defendants by their counsel objected, but the objection was overruled by the court and the bond permitted to go as evidence to the jury. To this ruling of the court the objectors excepted and now assign the same for error in the appellate court.
The bond was a joint and several obligation, and had the obligor liuckman, whose signature had been proved, been sued alone, a recovery might have been had against him on the evidence adduced, and since by the statute, Code 1860, chap. 177, sec. 19, a like, recovery might have been had against the same obligor in this action, upon the same evidence, it was proper-to permit the evidence to go to the jury for that purpose, and would have been error in the court to have excluded it from the jury as required by the defendants in the court below.
Had the court been asked to instruct the jury that the said bond, so proved against one, and not against the other obligors, was only evidence against the one and not against the others, it would certainly have been the duty of the court to have done so. But no such instruction having been asked, no objection can bo raised on that account to the failure of the court to do what it was not asked to do.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit