Supreme Court of Iowa January 23, 1867 (Robey & Robey v. Knowlton)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-01-1867
Wright, J.
*5451 LimitationeivSenceof: defendant. *544The defendant’s testimony was substantially as follows: I made the note and have since paid it; *545my wife was tf16 widow of True Eobey, deceased, and mother of plaintiffs; I was told that the note was given for my wife’s share in her former husband’s real estate; there was no other consideration, and it was given as a voucher for such share; the guardian (Osborne) had received the money and wanted something to show that she had received the same; he deceased some time in 1865, and never claimed that I owed the note; I never knew plaintiffs had the note until about the time this suit was commenced; they got their share of the estate by way of compromise; I offered a horse for the note; I married the widow in 1846 and received the money in 1848; my wife and plaintiffs were the only heirs; could not, at the time the note was given, read writing; don’t know that I gave a mortgage to secure the note; I used the money, and the wife died in December, 1865; don’t know whether the money was my wife’s absolutely, or whether she was simply entitled to a life use of it; the indorsement on the note was made at the time it was executed; I received the money as my wife’s, and offered the horse only as a compromise.
Upon these facts the question is, whether the court should have found, in the language of the statute, that, from the testimony of defendant, it affirmatively appears that “the cause of action still justly subsists.” Eev. § 2742. It will be seen that the statute requires that the cause of action shall appear to still justly subsist from the defendants testimony, and that this shall be thus shown affirmatively. And, therefore, however strong and conclusive may be the other testimony, it will not avail unless the court can say that the case is taken out of the statute affirmatively by his oath.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit