Supreme Court of Iowa January 27, 1867 (Packer v. Packer)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-01-1867
Dillon, Ch. J.
The first question made is, did the court err in refusing the defendant a trial by jury % The 1. juey: costs, defendant, in the answer filed in the District Court, did not plead that by agreement of the parties, the plaintiff was to pay the costs. He simply set up the receipt or release. This instrument the plaintiff did not deny or controvert. Thus, the only question left was, who should pay the costs ? The ecvuse ofacUon was undeniably settled by the parties; and there was no pleading setting up a contract, other than the release or receipt, that plaintiff was to pay the costs. Under these circumstances we hold that the court did not err in refusing the defendant’s “ demand for a tidal by jury.” What issue or fact he wished the jury to try was not stated to the court, nor did it appear from the pleadings. The meaning or construction of the receipt or release would present a question of law for the court, not of fact for the jury. This disposes of one question made by the appellant.
2. costs .- a®davits: practice. The only other question, relates to the admissibility of affidavits by the court to aid it in determining the question as to who should pay the costs. Appelx ° x 1 lant contends that the evidence should have been oral or by deposition so that he could have had an opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses. It is very usual to determine questions of costs upon motion or in a summary manner; and to receive affidavits to assist in such determination. Such a practice finds a warrant in various provisions of the statute (ch. 137, §§ 3328, 3440, 3442, 3447, 3448, 3452, 3461, 3465).
If the court had refused to the defendant the like privilege of using affidavits, or if the court upon defendant’s *23application and a showing, had refused to allow him an opportunity to cross-examine the affiants, or to take from them explanatory or counter affidavits, a very different question would be presented for our determination.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit