Tennessee Supreme Court April 15, 1867 (Shirley v. Keathy)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-04-1867
Milligan, J.,
delivered the opinion of the Court.
This is an action of verbal slander. There are three counts in the declaration. The defamatory words imputed to' the defendant, in the first and second counts of the declaration, import a charge of larceny; and in the third count, a fraudulent breach of trust. The defendant pleads “in short,” a.s it it is denominated, “not guilty and justification,” upon which, as it appears, “the plaintiff takes issue.” These laconic paragraphs, constitute the whole of the pleas, replications and issues. They are marked in the record, and respectively signed by the opposing counsel.
On the trial, after the jury was impanneled and sworn, and the testimony in chief closed, the defendant, by leave of the Court, and “consent of the parties,” withdrew his so-called plea of justification, and the cause proceeded to final judgment, on the plea of “not guilty” alone.
There were verdict and judgment for the plaintiff, and an appeal in error to this Court.
1st, The proof establishes the defamatory words, as laid in the declaration, and shows that the property about which the accusation of larceny, or fraudulent breach of trust, was made, was a quantity of corn and shucks, left by the defendant, in the care and custody of the plaintiff. And during the progress of the trial, and after the so-called plea of justification was withdrawn, the defendant proposed to prove, in mitigation of damages, that he had left the corn, about which the slanderous words were spoken, in the care, and under the control of, plaintiff, *31and that a portion of it had been lost -while in his custody. The Court refused to admit the testimony, on the ground that it tended to prove the truth of the defamation. The defendant excepted, at the time, to the ruling of the Court, and insists on it as error, for which judgment ought to he reversed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit