Supreme Judicial Court of Maine July 1, 1868 (Doyle v. Donnelly)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-07-1868

Barrows, J.

— Whatever defects there may be in the defendants’ specifications, the accord and satisfaction is well specified, and if the instructions of the presiding Judge, and the finding of the jury relative to that adjustment are sustained, it is of no consequence whether all the aggravations of the trespass alleged were specifically denied or not.

The defendants, father and son, are charged in an action of trespass, q. c., with breaking and entering the plaintiff’s dwellinghouse, breaking his stove in pieces, and assaulting the plaintiff with a pistol, expelling him from the possession of the premises and keeping him out some three or four weeks. There was a controversy as to the right to the possession of the lot of land on which the house stood. It belonged to the State, and, while one or both of the defend*28ants had been in possession, the legal right to the possession at the time of this quarrel would seem to have been in the plaintiff, who had the permission of the local land agent, subsequently ratified by the land agent of the State. One of the defendants helped build the house and had some articles of personal property in it when the plaintiff took possession. The defendants assert that a previous trespass and the first assault on this occasion were committed by the plaintiff against them, and they offer testimony to prove that, some days after this affair, plaintiff came to the house of the elder Donnelly to settle it up, and it was there agreed that no suits should be commenced.by either party against the other. In the language of one of the defendants, "Doyle wanted to drop all, and we not sue him, or he us. We agreed to it and shook hands on it,—parted good friends, and the whole matter was settled.” The plaintiff denies that any such adjustment ever took place.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.