Supreme Court of Pennsylvania May 18, 1868 (Commonwealth v. Ocean Oil Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-05-1868
The opinion of the court was delivered, May 27th 1868, by
Read, J.
The capital of oil companies is generally nominal, and when therefore the capital of this company is called $1,000,000, it is very evident that this sum was not paid for the 4 acres of land, but that it was valued for the purposes of a division into stock at one million. “ Some stock sold at $4, some .$20 per share,” says the treasurer, “original shares sold low— land had not been developed then.”
This company calling and returning its capital at one million, is taxed upon its capital stock at that sum, but by the Act of-the 30th April 1864, Pamph. L. 218, the “ net earnings or income” of said corporation are subjected to a state tax of “ three per centum upon such annual net earnings or income, in addition to the taxes now imposed by existing laws.”
The question therefore is, what is the meaning of “ net earnings or income?” Does it mean, as it was construed by the treasurer in his report to the auditor-general, the product of the business after deducting expenses only ? if so, then the settlement by the auditor-general and state treasurer is correct.
But it is contended by the company, that the annual product must first be applied to the repayment of capital, and this would leave no net earnings or income to tax. The court below compromised between these two constructions, and held that there must be an application of so much of the annual product, as would repay the capital, in the probable number of years that oil would *64flow or be taken from the land, and then the surplus would be the net earnings or income subject to taxation. This mode requires the interposition of a jury wherever there is a difference of opinion between the company and the state authorities,
f I can see no warrant for such a reading of the law.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit