Tennessee Supreme Court April 15, 1868 (Jones v. Thomas)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-04-1868

Henry Gr. Smith, J.,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

*466Assumpsit for the price of cotton, etc., sold and delivered in 1862, by Thomas to Jones; general issue, verdict and judgment for Thomas; and appeal in error to this Court, by Jones.

The supposed error is found in the charge of the .'Circuit Judge to the jury.

-Jones’ defense was, that he had paid and settled •the debt not long after it was contracted. It appeared that his alleged payment was in part, $400 in Confederate currency;' and upon the evidence, a question to the jury was, whether Thomas accepted the currency in fact, and -whether such acceptance ’ was voluntary, or done under the stress of threats and intimidation.

The Court, among other things, charged the jury, that, if the contract between the parties had been executed, and the plaintiff received payment in Confederate currency, taking the same cheerfully and . of his own free will and accord, and acknowledging the same a satisfaction, or settlement of the indebtedness of the defendant, then the plaintiff would not be entitled to a verdict, but the verdict should be for the defendant. If, however, the plaintiff had received the Confederate currency by reason of intimidation, or on account of fraudulent representations made to him by the defendant, this would not be a legal execution of the contract, and the plaintiff would be entitled to recover.

The obvious force of these instructions upon the mind of the jury, is, that the acceptance of Confederate currency in payment and settlement of a debt, must be, on the part of the creditor, done cheerfully and of his own free will and accord, and without any in*467timidation; otherwise, such acceptance will not he effective to bar action by the creditor to recover the debt as unpaid and unsettled. In such sense, the instructions were erroneous.

This Court held, in Hanly vs. Franklin, 3 Cold.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.