District Court, N.D. Illinois December 15, 1868 (In re Clark)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1868
DBUMMOND, District Judge.
In this case the register of the first district has certified to the court that there is no opposition to the discharge of the bankrupt by any creditor, and that he is entitled to his discharge provided it is competent in law to discharge an involuntary bankrupt,
I .understand, also, that doubt has been expressed on this point in other quarters, and I have therefore examined the question. It is rather singular that' the bankrupt law nowhere refers in express words to the discharge of an involuntary bankrupt, but I think that the necessary conclusion from the whole law is, that the fact of the applicant being an ■ involuntary bankrupt should not of itself alone prevent his discharge.
The 42d section declares, that “the warrant shall be directed, and the property of the debtor shall be taken thereon and shall be assigned and distributed in the same manner and with similar proceedings to those hereinbefore provided for the taking possession, assignment, and distribution of the property of the debtor upon his own petition.” The object in both cases — voluntary and involuntary — is the same, the distribution of the assets of the bankrupt among his creditors in conformity with the modes pointed out by the law.
Undoubtedly, if the act of bankruptcy alleged and proved against the involuntary bankrupt comes within any of the alternatives specified in the 29th section, which prevent or render invalid any discharge, he should not be discharged; but if there be nothing of that kind set forth in the petition by the creditor, nor otherwise shown, I see no good reason why the party should be compelled to go through the vain cere*841mony of filing a petition himself, to be released from his debts, when his debts and assets have just been administered by the bankrupt court, at the instance of a credit- or.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit